I’m a Forgotten Realms player from my 2nd edition AD&D days, which means I got exposed to the setting right around the time that Elminster the Sage was crammed down players’ throats everywhere. He showed up in the majority of Realms fiction, bothered PCs during official adventure modules, and even showed up to meddle with affairs in the Baldur’s Gate videogames.
I’ve discussed how annoying I found Elminster in those days, and I’ve tried to avoid turning the uber-powerful mage of my own setting into a character with those same flaws. However, I don’t think that Elminster is necessarily bad for the Forgotten Realms setting. It’s just his presentation that tends to be bad.
Here are a few optional takes on Elminster that might make him more interesting. Each of these takes assumes the same Elminster that appears in the 3rd edition Forgotten Realms Campaign Setting – the 30+ level character with silver fire and a +5 longsword that he has no reason to use. So in each model, he’s a being of demigod-level might who can wreck worlds. But that doesn’t mean he has to be as smug and boring as he appears in official fiction and adventure modules. Continue reading